Anatomy of a Deal Gone Bad	The Maddux Fiasco Part III: Who Wanted What? a baseballyarn inquiry		Part I                             Part II Part III Part IV                             Part V
The Braves signed Maddux, leaving us with some some basic questions!
The Player Greg Maddux Did he really want to be a Cub?	Quick Quote "We don't have any money." Larry Himes to Scott Boras (December 9, 1992)		The Agent Scott Boras Did he actually call the shots?
The Baseball Exec Larry Himes Did he really want Maddux?			The Corporate Exec Stanton Cook Did he actually call the shots?
We don't know how to account for some of the variations in the basic story--for example . . .
First Offer (Dec. 3, 1991) Cubs offer to Player. . . $5,000,000 a year for 5 years Historic amount for a pitcher Player and Agent do not respond	Alternate version of First Offer Maddux declines original offer because it lacks a no-trade clause! He then changes his mind and tells team clause not necessary! Cubs then stall and shilly-shally and do not get back to him! Maddux demands that Cubs respond by specific date and time! 5 minutes after deadline, Cubs tell him offer has been withdrawn!		If true, it represents a Display of Pettiness . . . by the player for      making such a demand . . . by Cub executives for      letting the deadline pass
And there are two ways of interpreting Himes' complaint about bidding against himself. . .
Himes upped his original offer from 25 to 27.5 million Boras was not satisfied with the new amount He wanted Himes to boost it to 30 million ("6 for 5") No other team has been able to make an offer yet and . . . Himes is supposed to keep bidding against himself?		To Boras, Himes is not bidding against himself He is bidding on the player's value, which is rising By mid-1992, Maddux was an All Star (and Himes upped the payout) By the end of 1992 he was a 20-game winner! And Himes should boost the contract still further!
Home       Start	Larry Himes (Cub GM)	More Cubs Stuff	Features